The customer site presented in this case study is the premiere provider of drip irrigation tape, tubing and
related accessories for agriculture companies looking to increase crop yields through efficient water
delivery. Their manufacturing facility produces plastic drip tubing and parts on injection molding and
The heads of the injection and extrusion machines are cooled using air-cooled process chillers. The facility
previously had two chilled water loops, one chilled water loop served the extrusion machines and the
other chilled water loop served the injection molding machines. Two (2) 75 ton air-cooled chillers served
the molding chiller water loop, and three (3) air-cooled chillers served the extrusion chilled water
loop. Of the three (3) that served the extrusion loop, one was rated at 110 tons and the other two (2)
rated at 40 tons.
The facility also utilized four (4) chilled water pumps, two (2) chilled water pumps serve the extrusion
and molding loop, with 30 hp motors operating constantly. Each chilled water loop also had a separate
10 hp circulating pump that transferred water from the holding tank to the chillers for cooling. The
chilled water header and piping however were undersized for the amount of chilled water flow required
by the facility.
The old process chillers suffered from a number of inefficiencies. They were operating at high condensing
pressures, which increased the energy consumption of the chillers for cooling. Mixing the chilled water,
supplied by the chillers, with the chilled water in the tank resulted in higher chilled supply temperatures.
They were also very old with poor efficiencies.
Lockheed Martin Energy engineers conducted an audit on the chilled water system and replaced the air cooled
chillers with two water cooled screw chillers. An oversized evaporative condenser was also installed
to provide condensing temperatures close to the outdoor wet bulb temperature. The chilled water return
tanks were also raised six feet above the chilled water pumps, providing gravity fed water through the
pipes. Properly sized piping was also installed and the four (4) 30hp chilled water pumps were replaced
with two (2) properly sized chilled water pumps rated at 15 hp.
Implementation of these measures saved 2,132,005 kWh annually, corresponding to a cost savings of $234,521
yearly. These savings made the simple payback period only 0.5 years!
Program Pacific Gas and
Lockheed Martin Energy
Heavy Industry Energy Efficiency
Reduce the energy needed to cool the injection and extrusion machines
Replace the aircooled chillers with watercooled chillers, upgrade the chilled water pump system
2,132,005 kWh annually
Peak Energy Savings:
Carrier 30HXA096 100 ton water-cooled chiller
Carrier 30HXA136 150 ton water-cooled chiller
Evapco PMC-889E evaporative condenser
(2) 15 HP chilled water pumps
Properly sized piping for the chilled water header
LME Paid Incentive
Energy Cost Savings
It is our objective to assist PG&E heavy industry customers in:
Improve product quality and production rate
Identify process-focused energy efficiency improvements and other opportunities
Facilitate electricity and natural-gas energy efficiency equipment and demand reduction upgrades
Reduce operating costs per unit of product
Reduce waste, pollutants, and Green House Gas emissions
Increased production efficiency = Lower production costs = Increased profits